Understanding the FICA tip credit for restaurants, bars, and other food and drink establishments

Only cash/debit/credit tips that exceed an amount of $20 during a single calendar month must be reported and have taxes withheld. As an employer, you are responsible for reporting tips on a quarterly basis, as part of your quarterly tax return. You also must collect employee income, Social Security, and Medicare tax on tips reported by employees.

• Enforcement of these guidelines for reporting of tip income is
  difficult without the absolute cooperation of employers.
• If your regular pay in your paycheck is insufficient to cover all your tax withholdings on your regular pay plus your tipped income, then you will have to pay your employer money to cover the rest of the taxes.
• Forms 941 and W-2 will
  require employers to separately report these amounts.
• Tax Return for Seniors, and the employee share of Social Security and Medicare tax owed on those tips.
• Tipping is a custom in the U.S., but it varies in use around the world.
• This “employer only” and “employer first” approach by the IRS is therefore the motivating factor that encourages owners to sign tip agreement contacts.

In the case of catered affairs
and banquets, the amount so charged is agreed upon in advance by the
customer and management. Because the service charge is considered a
part of gross recipts, many state tax authorities have argued that it
should be subject to a sales tax. However, a discussion of that issue
is beyond the scope of this article. Tip income has been scrutinized more than ever during the past five
years. The IRS estimates that 84% of tip income, approximately $500
million each year, is never reported. TEFRA 82 was designed to provide
for reporting of tips by employees of food and beverage establishments.

Tip allocation in large food and beverage establishments

An amended Form W-2 must also be issued to an employee if the tip allocation varies by more than 5 percent from the actual amount of his tips. Form 8027 must be filed by the last day of February (the filing date is March 31 if you file electronically) of the year following the calendar year for which the return is made. You are not responsible for verifying the accuracy of the amount of tip income your employees report to you. Rather, the employees are responsible for the accuracy of their own tip reports.

As a practical matter you cannot force your employees to report all their tip income, and be assured, they will not! While you are legally responsible for distributing Form 4070A (or an acceptable alternative) the restaurant is only liable for its share of the FICA taxes on unreported tips (and only if the IRS is successful at substantiating unreported https://turbo-tax.org/employer-payroll-tax-obligations-for-tipped/ tip income). While that may sound to you like an acceptable risk to take, just think of the liability that might accrue over a year or more if such an audit were to take place. You must therefore take a pro-active role in educating, prodding, cajoling, and annoying, if necessary, your employees to get them to accurately report their tips.

Reporting Tips Allocated by Your Employer

If the result of this calculation is more than 80 hours, you are considered to have employed more than 10 employees on a typical business day. If you are a food service employer, you can agree to take certain steps to increase tip reporting compliance by your employees in exchange for a promise by the IRS not to demand more FICA than you determine to be due. Destination Unknown Restaurants, a Washington D.C.-based restaurant group started by Josh and Kelly Phillips, reopened after a pandemic pause in summer 2020 with a problem.

When you receive the tip report from your employee, use it to figure the amount of social security, Medicare and income taxes to withhold for the pay period on both wages and reported tips. You’re responsible for paying the employer’s portion of the social security and Medicare taxes. Additionally, the IRS states that this credit only applies to taxes paid after December 31, 1993, and only applies to tips received by food and beverage employees. Employers must furnish their employees with a statement indicating the
amount of FICA tax due on allocated tips that exceeds the amount the
employer was able to withhold. Some businesses, such as restaurants, assume that employees will earn tips; thus, these businesses will provide a lower hourly wage rate.

Should Your Restaurant Get Rid of Tipping?

A tipped employee engages in an occupation in which he or she customarily and regularly receives more than $30 per month in tips. An employer of a tipped employee is only required to pay $2.13 per hour in direct wages if that amount combined with the tips received at least equals the federal minimum wage. If the employee’s tips combined with the employer’s direct wages of at least $2.13 per hour do not equal the federal minimum hourly wage, the employer must make up the difference. Many states, however, require higher direct wage amounts for tipped employees. Employees are responsible for reporting all cash tips they have earned so the appropriate taxes can be withheld from their paycheck.

To qualify for overtime under federal law, an employee must work more than 40 hours in a single workweek. Under the FLSA, those overtime hours must be paid at one and a half times the usual regular rate for the time worked. Instructions and forms for reporting tips to employers are found in Publication 1244. Employees can use this form https://turbo-tax.org/ or they can also create a custom form or even just write down a record of tips with pen and paper. You should communicate to your employees how you would like them to report on tips. States that do not have laws prohibiting deducting fees, but have ruled “tips are the property of the employee” include Kentucky, Montana, and Colorado.

Employer’s Federal Unemployment Tax Return

Tips are discretionary, which means that the customer must choose to give a tip. They have the right to choose the amount of the gratuity and the recipient. Any employee who receives more than $20 a month in tipped income must report their earnings. If there isn’t enough, the employer must first apply money to taxes on the regular pay (the hourly wage), then FICA taxes on the tips, and finally withholding for federal and state taxes. Department of Labor shows state requirements for paying tipped employees minimum wages as of January 2022. Additional Medicare Tax applies to an individual’s Medicare wages that exceed a threshold amount based on the taxpayer’s filing status.

Even though these reports are only due once a month, employers should collect this report at the end of every pay period. IRS Publication 1244 includes instructions and forms for this purpose. The bottom line is this� restaurant employees are required to
report and pay taxes on all their wages including tips. Since most tipped
employees may receive a significant amount of their income in the form of
“cash” tips, it is no wonder that they are reluctant to fully report this
income. It is one of the reasons that working as a waiter in full service
restaurant can be so appealing.

Power your business with Square

Withhold any remaining unpaid federal income taxes from the employee’s next paycheck, up to the close of the calendar year. However, if you can’t collect all of the employee’s social security and Medicare taxes on tips by the 10th day of the month following the month in which your employee reported the tips, you don’t have to collect the taxes. Show the uncollected amount as an adjustment on your employment tax return (for example, Form 941, Employer’s QUARTERLY Federal Tax Return).

In general, employee tip income is treated as employer provided wages for purposes of social security and medicare withholding under the Federal Insurance Contributions Act (“FICA”). Employees are also required to report to their employer the amount of tips received. However, to relieve the financial burden, the federal government allows eligible business owners to claim a FICA tip tax credit each year on their returns. You may have heard about some restaurants that have chosen to do away with tipping in favor of offering their employees a higher hourly wage. There’s support for both sides of this argument, including concerns about inconsistent earnings and support for tipping’s motivational influence on servers. Let’s explore this topic and discuss the effects tipping can have on your restaurant business.

Tip Calculations on Customer’s Check are Not Service Charges

An employee must use Form 4137, Social Security and Medicare Tax on Unreported Tip Income, to report the amount of any unreported tip income to include as additional wages on their Form 1040, U.S. Tax Return for Seniors, and the employee share of Social Security and Medicare tax owed on those tips. Regardless of the tip income reported on Form 8027, you are required to withhold income tax and Social Security tax only on the tips actually reported by employees. These forms are transmitted with Form 8027-T, Transmittal of Employer’s Annual Information Return of Tip Income and Allocated Tips, if you have more than one establishment. If this process leaves you with insufficient funds to collect the employee’s FICA tax, your obligation to withhold the uncollected portion ends. In contrast, any outstanding income tax collections should be withheld from your next payment of wages to the employee.

• This tax credit can save restaurant owners a significant amount of money as it directly reduces the amount of taxes owed.
• These forms are transmitted with Form 8027-T, Transmittal of Employer’s Annual Information Return of Tip Income and Allocated Tips, if you have more than one establishment.
• Under TRAC, employers are required to educate employees on their reporting obligations and institute formal tip-reporting procedures.
• If none of your employees earned at least $20 per month in reportable tips which would necessitate this tax payment, you cannot claim the FICA tip credit.
• As an employer, you are responsible for reporting tips on a quarterly basis, as part of your quarterly tax return.
• You can’t use a reduced percentage before receiving notice in writing from the IRS that the petition is approved.

But you can use the tip amount to offset what the Department of Labor calls the “required cash wage,” which is $2.13. The difference between the required cash wage and the 2022 minimum wage of $7.25 is assumed to be made up by tips. You must withhold income taxes and FICA taxes on tip income in your calculation of wage payments. Tip income is also subject to both the maximum Social Security limit and the additional Medicare tax. When preparing an employee’s Form W-2, include wages, tips, and other compensation in the box labeled “Wages, tips, other compensation.” Include Medicare wages and tips, and social security tips in their respective boxes. When figuring the employer’s liability for federal unemployment tax, add the reported tips to the employee’s wages.